Short-Term Health Insurance – Affordable, But at What Cost?

Health insurance is essential for protecting both your financial and personal well-being. However, not everyone has equal access to affordable health plans. For many, short-term health insurance appears to be a good choice due to its lower premiums and fewer benefits.

But as one individual discovered, these policies can come with hidden costs, leading to hefty bills for essential medical procedures. This case highlights the risks of choosing short-term health insurance over more comprehensive options, especially when the unexpected happens.

The Risk of Choosing Short-Term Health Insurance

Tim Winard, like many others, opted for short-term health insurance after leaving his full-time job to start his own business. He was concerned about the cost of a plan under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). After consulting with an insurance agent, he decided on a short-term policy, believing it would provide enough coverage until his business was up and running.

At first, the policy seemed like a good fit. It was affordable, costing about $500 a month, and it covered both him and his wife. However, Winard didn’t fully understand the limitations of his coverage, especially regarding how medical procedures would be billed.

The Colonoscopy Experience

Instagram | anmed_health | Winard underwent a recommended colonoscopy for routine colorectal cancer screening.

At 57, Winard needed a colonoscopy, a routine procedure recommended for individuals at average risk for colon cancer starting at age 45. He was advised to have the procedure to rule out any concerns. The colonoscopy was performed at a hospital in Elmhurst, Illinois, and everything seemed fine. However, when Winard received the bill, things quickly turned south.

The total cost for the colonoscopy was $10,723.19, including anesthesia and recovery room fees. After applying an insurance discount, his short-term health insurance covered only a small portion—$817.47. Winard was left with a staggering $7,226.71 to pay out-of-pocket.

The Gaps in Short-Term Health Insurance Coverage

Short-term health insurance is designed for temporary coverage, often lasting only a few months. While it may appear to be an affordable option, it doesn’t follow the same regulations as ACA plans. This means it can leave policyholders with limited coverage for medical expenses.

One of Winard’s biggest surprises was how unclear his policy was about what it actually covered. Short-term plans often impose strict limits on how much they’ll pay for certain services, such as outpatient procedures. In Winard’s case, the colonoscopy and related expenses fell under an “outpatient surgery facility” benefit, which had a daily cap of $1,000. This cap was far below the actual cost of the procedure.

Understanding the Fine Print

Short-term plans are notorious for unclear terms, which can be hard for consumers to interpret. In this case, the insurance company argued that the colonoscopy was considered outpatient surgery, a classification Winard hadn’t expected. His policy stated it would cover 80% of the costs for colon cancer screenings, but the coverage limits meant that even after meeting his deductible, Winard still faced most of the bill.

Many people, like Winard, may not realize that short-term insurance plans often exclude essential health benefits like maternity care and prescription drug coverage. These policies may also exclude coverage for preexisting conditions or reject applicants with certain health issues. While they are more affordable, they are less comprehensive than ACA plans.

The Impact of Political Changes on Short-Term Plans

Short-term health insurance has been a political topic for years. Under the Obama administration, these plans were limited to three months to prevent them from replacing comprehensive ACA coverage. However, the Trump administration extended their duration to up to 364 days. Recently, the Biden administration moved to limit these plans to four months again.

These regulatory shifts directly affect how short-term plans are marketed and sold. While they may seem like an affordable alternative, especially compared to ACA plans, they come with many risks and limitations that people may not fully understand.

How to Avoid Unexpected Bills

Freepik | Before choosing a health plan, especially a short-term one, know its coverage and costs.

The main takeaway from Winard’s experience is the importance of thoroughly reviewing any health insurance policy before signing up. Short-term health plans can be tempting because of their low premiums, but it’s crucial to understand their exclusions, coverage limits, and out-of-pocket costs.

Before enrolling in a short-term plan, consumers should:

– Carefully read the policy’s terms and conditions, paying attention to exclusions and limits on coverage.
– Ensure the plan covers essential health benefits, such as preventive screenings and prescription drugs.
– Always request a written cost estimate for nonemergency procedures like a colonoscopy to avoid unexpected bills.
– Compare the total costs of a short-term plan with an ACA plan, which may offer subsidies and broader coverage options based on income.

Is Short-Term Health Insurance Worth It?

Although short-term health insurance may seem like a budget-friendly option, it’s essential to consider the potential drawbacks before choosing it. Winard’s experience serves as a warning of how these plans, while affordable, can lead to financial strain when unexpected medical procedures arise. The lower premiums may not justify the risk of having to pay out-of-pocket for major medical expenses.

For many, the better option may be a comprehensive ACA plan that offers more extensive coverage, even if the premiums are higher. With subsidies available for those who qualify, an ACA plan might end up being more affordable than expected, offering better protection and fewer surprises with medical bills.

Ultimately, understanding the details of any health insurance plan—short-term or otherwise—is vital for making an informed decision about your health and finances.